The Daily Gazette - Schenectady, NY
Daily Gazette

Tax activist: Say no to buses
Saturday, July 12, 2008

Text Size: A | A | A

— As a school bus referendum draws closer, one activist is urging voters to shoot down the proposed purchase.

Ordinarily, said taxpayer activist Jack Kinzie, he would support the Gloversville school district’s proposal to buy $190,000 worth of buses when the local share of the purchase is only $19,000.

Kinzie supported the proposal last August when the district held a special election to try a second time to win approval for five buses at a total cost of $450,000, but a local cost of only $45,000.

In a situation that closely mirrors the district’s election choices in 2007, Gloversville voters will be asked to give buses a second look in a special Aug. 18 election. Voters rejected the purchase the first time around, in May.

“We both know financially it’s foolish to reject an opportunity to buy buses at 10 cents on the dollar,” Kinzie told a reporter. “But,” he said, “that school board shafted the public and I advocate we shaft them back.”

Kinzie said he is angry that the board responded to an over 2-to-1 rejection of the $50.7 million budget and its 6.9 percent tax increase by adopting an almost identical contingency budget with the same tax increase.

Board President Perry Paul said he understands Kinzie’s point of view, but said that cuts in past years went so deep there were no apparent options to reduce the tax increase.

Just to support spending levels from last year, Paul said, required a 4.7 percent tax levy increase and that did not address increasing costs for utility bills, health insurance and other contractual employee costs.

Paul said Kinzie’s real grievance is with the state, which establishes the mandated costs and methods for adopting a contingency budget.

If the state Department of Transportation inspects the district’s buses and takes some off the road, Paul said, a failure to buy two vehicles at 10 cents on the dollar might compel the district into a situation where it must pay full price for replacements.

School officials said the $190,000 could buy two large buses or one large bus, two vans and a Suburban.

Last year, the budget and buses were both rejected in May, but after the board offered a zero tax increase, they were approved in separate special elections.

This past May, voters turned down the budget, 1,189 to 513, but rejected the buses by a much closer 876-to-728 vote.

In June, after those rejections, the board voted to adopt a contingency budget only $4,000 less than the first proposal but opted to hold a new bus election.

Kinzie, founder of Fulton County Taxpayers Association, closely monitors school districts and local governments. He attends meetings, writes letters, and has a public access television show to further his message, and has gained some influence in his role.

He said he is growing more exasperated as the school board is finding ways to reverse budget cuts made before the May election, including elimination of three elementary librarian positions at a cost of $200,000 and seventh-grade sports at a cost of over $40,000.

Kinzie said he supported maintaining those two items in the original budget because librarians and sports are part of what he called the core educational program. But, he said, the way it is being handled is an affront to the taxpayers.

The $200,000 used to restore the library positions, he said, is the supplemental aid obtained by state Sen. Hugh T. Farley, R-Niskayuna, after the budget rejection. Kinzie said that funding should have been used for tax stability.

Kinzie said the board owed it to taxpayers to make a concerted effort to trim the tax increase before adopting a contingency budget.



Share story:   print   email +digg
+fark
+reddit
+facebook
+del.icio.us
+stumbleupon

comments


July 13, 2008
6:57 a.m.

[ Suggest removal ]
sbdknitter ( no real name given ) says...

Who will suffer if the school bus proposition is voted down? You and I, my fellow taxpayers, as well as our children. If Gloversville has the opportunity to purchase buses at ten cents on the dollar (which is not a rate every school district qualifies for) and doesn't do it then we could be stuck paying full price for those same vehicles.
DOT inspects school buses twice a year and if they are unsafe for the transportation of children the bus is put out of service. Does this depend on whether or not the district has voted for or against a bus proposition? No.
Are there ways the school board could save taxpayers money? Undoubtedly. But being forced to maintain vehicles that are over ten years old with hundreds of thousands of miles on them? It is just to ridiculous to even think about.

July 13, 2008
9:01 a.m.

[ Suggest removal ]
Adirondackal ( no real name given ) says...

"If Gloversville has the opportunity to purchase buses at ten cents on the dollar" etc etc. Do people not realize that we are paying the other ninety cents through our state taxes? Taking from our left pocket to put in our right is fine for the out of touch school boards who serve their friends and families rather than the taxpayers who elect them. Gloversville is certainly one of the worst."It's for the cheeelllldrreeen they screach." Please come to our city and ask to view the Garagemahal a huge overpriced building "needed" to house all of these buses because the district won't contract out transportion or work with other districts to share services. The only people who "suffer" when the latest tax waster is voted down are the people who sell school buses.
And as for the Smithtown Svengali, aka Kinzie, I wish that you would stop referring to him as a "tax payer advocate." The taxpayers of our county had a chance to take back our county from the political machine when Kinzie the spoiler created a "write in" campaign out of whole cloth, splitting the opposition to the status quo candidate and insuring that the Republican power brokers continued to rule over us for at least two more years.

July 13, 2008
7:17 p.m.

[ Suggest removal ]
sbdknitter ( no real name given ) says...

Okay, vote down the bus proposition. Pay ten times the amount you could purchase the buses for. Blame the school board for that too. Will it reduce what we pay in taxes? Not a dime.

Post a comment
(Requires free registration.)

In Today's Gazette...
September 7, 2008

Poll
Should three Schenectady police officers face criminal charges for allegedly failing to fill out paperwork related to the use of force on a drunken driving suspect in December 2007?



See the results




Band of Liberty Tickets

Cool Cars for Hot Summer Contest

Ask A Doctor