The Daily Gazette - Schenectady, NY
Daily Gazette

Snowmobilers: Restore depleted funds
Saturday, June 28, 2008

Text Size: A | A | A

— When state officials took $1 million from the snowmobile trail maintenance fund to balance the 2008 budget, snowmobilers said they felt double-crossed.

After all, in accordance with a 2006 agreement with the state to address various trail issues, snowmachine registration fees were raised from $15 to $45 for club members and $100 for non-club members. There was an understanding that all registration money would go toward the program.

But, said Assemblyman Marc Butler, R-Newport, whose district includes the Northeast’s contending snowmobile capital Old Forge, the snowmobile fund was raided in April as state officials scrambled to balance and pass a budget.

“We were told there was a $1 million sweep from the Department of Environmental Conservation into the general fund, but it was only later we learned the money came from the trail maintenance fund,” Butler said.

Since April, there has been a cry from various North Country counties and the snowmobiling community to restore the money. The state Senate passed legislation restoring the money, but Butler said when the Assembly adjourned for the summer this week the measure was still in committee.

He and a number of colleagues went to Gov. Paterson’s office this week to present petitions with thousands of signatures from snowmobilers demanding restoration of the money.

Butler said Friday an aide to Paterson was receptive to the campaign and the plea to restore the money.

Butler, noting terms of the 2006 agreement in which the snowmobiling community consented to paying higher registration fees, said of the developments: “Quite rightfully they felt the state was dealing from the bottom of the deck. There was a commitment made and I really feel the state has an obligation,” Butler said.

Butler said maintaining the strength of the dedicated snowmobile Trail Development and Maintenance Fund is a financial and economic development issue affecting the entire state.

He said Old Forge, the Herkimer County snowmobiling hub that he called the capital of the Northeast “if not the nation,” is an important part of the state’s tourism industry.

Fulton County Clerk William Eschler, a member of the Bleecker Snow Rovers Snowmobile Club, said the state’s decision to take the money surprised him. “A dedicated fund should be untouchable,” said Eschler, who said state officials should not take any action that endangers the tourism industry.

A resolution recently adopted by the Warren County Board of Supervisors expressed support for the fund restoration bills in the Senate and Assembly.

The Warren County board said the trail improvements “are vital to rural communities as part of their efforts to grow their local economy.”

Warren County received $59,000 from the state trail fund last winter. County officials said it is unclear how the depletion of the state fund would affect this coming winter’s fund share.

Though last fall the state Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation allocated $2.8 million statewide to snowmobile clubs performing trail maintenance, agency spokeswoman Eileen Larrabee said the loss of $1 million in the fund will not affect this coming winter’s trail maintenance program.

Larrabee said the per-mile maintenance rates for 2008-09 have already been set. She said the lost money would be absorbed.

This past winter, she said, the state collected $5.4 million from the 128,283 snowmachine registrations. Registrations were down about 2,000 machines from the previous winter, she said.

The $5.4 million was allocated to various components of the snowmobile program, she said, including trail maintenance, law enforcement, insurance, administration and grants.

When registration fees were raised from $15 in 2006, there was an effort to encourage snowmobilers to join clubs.



Share story:   print   email +digg
+fark
+reddit
+facebook
+del.icio.us
+stumbleupon

comments


June 28, 2008
6:02 a.m.

[ Suggest removal ]
annarondac ( no real name given ) says...

How can this be legal?

June 28, 2008
2:04 p.m.

[ Suggest removal ]
akaGaGa ( no real name given ) says...

I don't know if it's legal, but I say, "Go ahead and raid it!" Why on earth is it the taxpayers responsibility to pay for somebody else to have fun? The money would be better left in our pockets to buy gas to get to work. If snowmobilers can pay outrageous prices for machines and the gas to run them, let THEM pay for trail maintenance. Not my job, man.

June 30, 2008
1:07 p.m.

[ Suggest removal ]
Snowmobiler ( no real name given ) says...

akaGaGa,

Please note, this fund does not contain any tax dollars. We snowmobilers have asked the state to raise our registration cost several times over the past decade to raise money for the trail fund. The DMV currently keeps $10 per registration to cover their administrative costs. The rest goes into the snowmobile trail development fund for use in building and maintaining snowmobile trails that are open to the public. The money also pays law enforcment, safety education and the salaries of state employees who run this program. Of all the special interest groups in New York State, we are one of the only ones that pay our own way without asking for money from the state. I repeat, these are not tax dollars and the taxpayer is not funding snowmobiling. These are funds that New York State Governement agreed to hold for us and to distribute back to municipalities and the clubs who build and maintain trails.

The snowmobile trail fund is a dedicated fund and New York has broken their promise by moving these funds to the general account to balance the budget.

June 30, 2008
2:18 p.m.

[ Suggest removal ]
JPP ( no real name given ) says...

akagaga, Snowmobiler was much more polite then I would have been. READ and KNOW your information before you make A hole remarks !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

June 30, 2008
6:18 p.m.

[ Suggest removal ]
Snowmobiler ( no real name given ) says...

A lot of people outside our community have no idea how this works-we aren't like lots of organizations asking the state to pay for this or build that. We try to ge that word out, but still not a lot of people understand that we are self-supporting and self sufficient.

We are all taxpayers too and don't want tax money spent on us-we do want New York State to keep their promises to us and not spend committed funds in the tax barrel with everything else-treating our trail fund as just another pot of tax money.

If New York can't make their budget on money they collect for that purpose, then NY State needs to learn some fiscal restraint-maybe a couple less NY State owned planes and helicopters-maybe make the lottery people drive their personal cars instead of us buying cars for them-there's lots of waste out there that could be cut before they need to attack dedicated funds-what they did to our fund is unconscionable.

July 1, 2008
10:16 a.m.

[ Suggest removal ]
annarondac ( no real name given ) says...

Thank you Snowmobiler. These facts should have been part of the story. Perhaps your organization needs more publicity as this seems to be a successful way to run government.

What the state did was absolutely wrong.

Post a comment
(Requires free registration.)

In Today's Gazette...
September 7, 2008

Poll
Should three Schenectady police officers face criminal charges for allegedly failing to fill out paperwork related to the use of force on a drunken driving suspect in December 2007?



See the results




Band of Liberty Tickets

Cool Cars for Hot Summer Contest

Ask A Doctor