Spa City plastic bag ban misguided

Saturday, March 9, 2013
Text Size: A | A

Increasing numbers of communities across the country are banning plastic shopping bags, so it’s not surprising to find a group of environmentally minded citizens calling for Saratoga Springs to follow suit. Their goal — encouraging consumers to use the most environmentally neutral way of transporting what they buy — is admirable, but their method is problematic.

Plastic bags are bad news for a number of reasons. They require a lot of oil to produce — roughly 35 million barrels for the 100 billion that retailers typically distribute each year. Relatively few of them get recycled (despite laws like New York’s, which require stores to provide collection bins); so they either wind up in landfills, taking up valuable space until they decompose (some are biodegradable these days), on the ground as litter, or wrapped around some innocent animal’s neck or in its stomach.

Paper may be a more benign alternative, but far from harmless: Growing and harvesting trees, and making paper, also consumes lots of energy and water. The paper must be bleached, using chemicals that are anything but good for the environment, and recycling it requires more energy than plastic.

Thus it almost seems unfair to focus on plastic bags, when paper ones aren’t much better.

Banning plastic in a city the size of Saratoga Springs would be challenging for a large chain retailer who relies on plastic bags in stores elsewhere. To buy a relatively small quantity of non-plastic bags for a small fraction of your stores would be expensive.

Obviously, the answer is to get more consumers to switch to heavier-duty, reusable bags, such those made out of canvas or recycled plastic. If there were a statewide, or at least regional effort to ban, or perhaps tax, disposable bags, that might be different. But the focus shouldn’t be on just plastic when plastic is not the only culprit.

Share story: print print email email facebook facebook reddit reddit


March 11, 2013
9:18 a.m.
tonijean613 says...

You hit the problem and nail on the head- You can't get consumers to do what they are supposed to do on their own because people are selfish and don't care-
Paper is 10x better than plastic because it can be harvested from sustainable air cleaning trees- not oil which is the only reason we are in endless war killing innocent people in foreign lands.
We need to stop taking other countries oil, and start moving away from fossil fuel consumption at home as soon as possible. Not many people understand plastic is made from oil, so any ban of plastic bags and enforcement of recycling of plastic in general is a win win for all PEOPLE, PEACE and the PLANET !! Our landfils are maxing out at record speed because of our throw away culture. NYS is actually many decades behind states like MA- when it comes to enforcing recycling, energy efficiency incentives, conservation and public transportation and walkable communities initiatives- all efforts that reduce pollution and reliance on fossil fuels- NYS should not be so far behind- we should be leading. Banning plastic bags and (plastic) bottled water- is a good start.

Log-in to post a comment.

columnists & blogs

Log into

Forgot Password?