Trump humiliated Sessions after Mueller appointment

PHOTOGRAPHER: The New York Times

President Donald Trump with Jeff Sessions at his ceremonial swearing-in as attorney general in February.

WASHINGTON — Shortly after learning in May that a special counsel had been appointed to investigate links between his campaign associates and Russia, President Donald Trump berated Attorney General Jeff Sessions in an Oval Office meeting and said he should resign, according to current and former administration officials and others briefed on the matter.

The president attributed the appointment of the special counsel, Robert S. Mueller III, on Sessions’ decision to recuse himself from the Justice Department’s Russia investigation — a move Trump believes was the moment his administration effectively lost control over the inquiry. Accusing Sessions of “disloyalty,” Trump unleashed a string of insults on his attorney general.

Ashen and emotional, Sessions told the president he would quit and sent a resignation letter to the White House, according to four people who were told details of the meeting. Sessions would later tell associates that the demeaning way the president addressed him was the most humiliating experience in decades of public life.

The Oval Office meeting, details of which have not previously been reported, shows the intensity of Trump’s emotions as the Russia investigation gained steam and how he appeared to immediately see Mueller’s appointment as a looming problem for his administration. It also illustrates the depth of antipathy Trump has had for Sessions — one of his earliest campaign supporters — and how the president interprets “disloyalty” within his circle of advisers.

Trump ended up rejecting Sessions’ May resignation letter after senior members of his administration argued that dismissing the attorney general would only create more problems for a president who had already fired an FBI director and a national security adviser. Trump once again, in July, told aides he wanted to remove Sessions, but for a second time didn’t take action.

The relationship between the two men has improved marginally since midsummer, as Sessions has made a public display of hunting for the leakers among the administration’s national security officials. His allies said that despite the humiliation, the attorney general has stayed in the job because he sees a “once-in-a-lifetime” opportunity as the nation’s top law enforcement official to toughen the country’s immigration policies.

But he may be losing that battle as well. Sessions played a prominent role announcing the end of the Obama-era program that provided protection to the children of unauthorized immigrants, only to see his boss backtrack on the policy. On Thursday morning, Trump confirmed he had reached a deal with Democrats to provide protections for the “Dreamers.”

This account is based on interviews with seven administration officials and others familiar with the interactions between Trump and Sessions in recent months who requested anonymity because they are not permitted to speak publicly about confidential conversations between the president and his aides. Politico first reported in July that Sessions had once offered his resignation letter, but the circumstances that prompted the letter — and Trump’s dressing down of the attorney general — have not previously been reported.

Press officers for the White House and Justice Department declined to comment.

The president’s outburst came in the middle of an Oval Office meeting that Trump had with top advisers on May 17 to discuss candidates to take over the FBI after the president fired its director, James Comey, earlier that month. In addition to Sessions, Vice President Mike Pence; Donald F. McGahn III, the White House counsel; and several other aides attended the meeting.

In the middle of the meeting, McGahn received a phone call from Rod J. Rosenstein, the deputy attorney general who had been overseeing the Russia investigation since Sessions recused himself from the inquiry months earlier. Sessions had stepped aside after it was revealed he had not provided accurate testimony to Congress about his meetings with the Russian ambassador during the presidential campaign.

In the telephone call to McGahn, Rosenstein said he had decided to appoint Mueller to be a special counsel for the investigation. Congress had been putting pressure on Rosenstein to appoint a special counsel to put distance between the Trump administration and the Russia investigation, and just the day before The New York Times had revealed that Trump had once asked Comey to end the FBI’s investigation into Michael Flynn, the former national security adviser.

When the phone call ended, McGahn relayed the news to the president and his aides. Almost immediately, Trump lobbed a volley of insults at Sessions, telling the attorney general it was his fault they were in the current situation. Trump told Sessions that choosing him to be attorney general was one of the worst decisions he had made, called him an “idiot,” and said that he should resign.

An emotional Sessions told the president he would resign and left the Oval Office. That evening, as the Justice Department publicly announced the appointment of Mueller, the attorney general wrote a brief resignation letter to the president that was later sent to the White House. A person familiar with the events raised the possibility that Sessions had become emotional because the impact of his recusal was becoming clear.

In the hours after the Oval Office meeting, however, Trump’s top advisers intervened to save Sessions’ job. Pence; Stephen Bannon, the president’s chief strategist at the time; and Reince Priebus, his chief of staff, all advised that accepting Sessions’ resignation would only sow more chaos inside the administration and rally Republicans in Congress against the president. Sessions, a former Alabama senator, served in the Senate for two decades.

The president relented, and eventually returned the resignation letter to Sessions — with a handwritten response on it.

For Sessions, the aggressiveness with which Trump has sought his removal was a blow. The son of a general store owner in a small town in Alabama, Sessions had long wanted to be the nation’s top federal law enforcement official or to serve in another top law enforcement or judicial post. He earned a reputation in the Senate as someone tough on immigration, and was the first senator to back Trump in the presidential campaign.

But their relationship began to deteriorate a little more than a month after Trump was sworn in as president, after Sessions’ announcement that he was recusing himself from the Russia inquiry caught Trump by surprise.

The president spent months stewing about the recusal. In a July 19 interview with The Times, Trump said he never would have appointed Sessions to be attorney general if he knew he was going to recuse himself from the Russia investigation. Trump called the decision “very unfair to the president.”

Days after the Times interview, Trump told aides he wanted to replace Sessions. Some of the president’s aides, not sure if Trump really wanted the attorney general gone or was just working through his anger, were able to delay the firing until the president’s anger passed.

But Trump continued his public attacks in the days that followed, including taking to Twitter to call him “weak” — a word that is among the harshest criticisms in Trump’s arsenal.

Administration officials and some of Trump’s outside advisers have puzzled at Sessions’ decision to stay on. But people close to Sessions said that he did not leave because he had a chance to have an impact on what he sees as a defining issue of his career: curtailing legal and illegal immigration.

In recent weeks, he has spearheaded the effort to undo what he believed to be the Obama administration’s dangerously lenient immigration policies, including the Deferred Action of Childhood Arrivals program.

Sessions had no illusions about converting Trump to his side of the argument — Trump remains deeply ambivalent — and he had no illusions about repairing a damaged relationship he had once regarded as a friendship. But he told people he felt he had successfully pushed the president toward ending the Obama immigration policy, and thought it had given him increased leverage in the West Wing.

The president agreed to terminate the program, and on Sept. 5 Sessions stood alone at a lectern — a moment that seemed to be a significant victory for the attorney general.

But his satisfaction was fleeting. Trump quickly undercut Sessions in a tweet by saying he would reconsider whether or not to end the program, leading the attorney general to tell allies that he was frustrated that the president had muddled months of work leading to the announcement of the new policy.

On Wednesday evening, Democrats announced they had reached a deal with the president to quickly extend protections for young unauthorized immigrants.

On Thursday morning, taking a vastly different position from the one Sessions had announced, the president tweeted about the need for protections for people brought here “through no fault of their own.”

On Thursday morning, taking a vastly different position than the one Sessions had announced on Sept. 5, the president tweeted about the need for protections for people brought here “through no fault of their own.”

…They have been in our country for many years through no fault of their own – brought in by parents at young age. Plus BIG border security

— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) September 14, 2017