Capital Region

Mayors plead for Capital Region cities to remain in single congressional district

JOHN CROPLEY/THE DAILY GAZETTESchenectady Mayor Gary McCarthy speaks on the subject of congressional redistricting at Albany City Hall on Wednesday, May 18, 2022. Watching from left are Albany Mayor Kathy Sheehan, Amsterdam Mayor Michael Cinquanti, Troy Mayor Patrick Madden and Saratoga Springs Mayor Ron Kim.

Schenectady Mayor Gary McCarthy speaks on the subject of congressional redistricting at Albany City Hall on Wednesday, May 18, 2022. Watching from left are Albany Mayor Kathy Sheehan, Amsterdam Mayor Michael Cinquanti, Troy Mayor Patrick Madden and Saratoga Springs Mayor Ron Kim.

ALBANY — Five mayors joined Wednesday to urge that Albany, Amsterdam, Saratoga Springs, Schenectady and Troy remain within a single congressional district. 

The five are the urban core of a region that combines to be more than the sum of its parts, they said, and needs a single voice representing it in Congress.

The cities themselves and the region would suffer under a proposed redistricting that would place Amsterdam and Saratoga Springs into a sprawling, mostly rural district that covers more than a quarter of the state’s land area, the mayors said.

“The most significant challenges and opportunities the city of Amsterdam deals with are pretty much identical to those faced by the municipalities represented by these four other mayors,” Amsterdam Mayor Michael Cinquanti said.

Albany Mayor Kathy Sheehan said the Capital Region is one of the few places in New York state that is gaining population and attracting new businesses, and it’s doing that because its municipalities work together and have a single representative advocating for them in the House of Representatives.

That would be U.S. Rep. Paul Tonko, D-Amsterdam, a veteran politician and seven-term congressman.

As it now exists, his 20th Congressional District accomplishes exactly what the mayors seek: It includes just enough of Rensselaer and Saratoga counties to include their two biggest cities, Troy and Saratoga Springs, plus the eastern end of Montgomery County, which includes Tonko’s lifelong home.

Congressional districts are redrawn every 10 years to reflect the latest census data. 

This time around, an independent bipartisan commission was to draw the map, but couldn’t agree on the district lines. So the job fell to the Democratic-controlled state Legislature, which drew up a set of maps that many said was severely gerrymandered — 22 of 26 districts would have a solid Democratic advantage in voter enrollment.

An appeals court with entirely Democratic appointees threw that map out. A court-appointed special master drew up new maps that were much less favorable to Democrats and, in the process, moved Amsterdam and Saratoga Springs into the 21st Congressional District, a massive area including all or part of 15 counties.

Tonko, who would be a resident of NY-21 under the proposed redistricting, plans to run for re-election in NY-20 if the new map is adopted as drawn. He does not have to live in the district he represents.

None of the mayors who spoke Wednesday mentioned Elise Stefanik, R-Schuylerville, the four-term incumbent who represents NY-21 and is running for re-election there. 

Stefanik has gained notice recently as a snarky, right-wing attack dog but the mayors’ objections seemed to be more against NY-21 than against its incumbent congresswoman or her politics.

“It’s a different congressional district made up of different types of communities, so I am very concerned,” said Cinquanti.

He noted Amsterdam would shift from a 1,000-square-mile district with several other cities to a 15,000-square-mile district with dispersed small towns.

“I’d much prefer having my representation come from the guy who’s representing the cities of the Capital District because those are the issues that mean the most to the city of Amsterdam.”

Schenectady would remain in NY-20 with the two other larger cities, Albany and Troy. But it would lose some clout without “unified advocacy,” Mayor Gary McCarthy said.

“Sometimes politics does enter into it,” he said. “Those communities are more Democratic. The role of public debate and then coming back together the next day and actually doing the work is gone in Washington. 

“So there is an element of partisanship, an element of divisiveness, that really affects local government and affects the nation as a whole. So I believe we’re really served by being in one district and having that common voice.”

Saratoga Springs Mayor Ron Kim said his city is especially reflective of the interconnected nature of the region because so many of its residents work in the other cities and so many residents from the other cities come to Saratoga for recreation.

“In many respects, we are one community separated by lines drawn on a map,” Troy Mayor Patrick Madden said.

The courts and special master invited public comment after releasing the draft maps Monday and Sheehan is optimistic they will take those comments into account. 

The public can comment via [email protected]. 

The maps are scheduled to be finalized Friday.

“We realize this is a really short time frame but we wouldn’t be doing this if we didn’t think we could have an impact,” Sheehan said.

As drawn, Albany, Rensselaer and Schenectady counties would be in NY-20, along with southern Saratoga County.

NY-21 would consist of Fulton, Herkimer, Montgomery, Schoharie, Warren and Washington counties, the northern half of Saratoga County, part of Otsego County, and all or part of seven other counties going north to the Canadian border.

Categories: Fulton Montgomery Schoharie, News, Saratoga County, Saratoga Springs, Schenectady, Schenectady County


William Marincic

So in essence these five Democrat mayors are trying to fix it so that Democrats will win in their districts. Wasn’t it enough when the legislature gave Kathy Hochul an advantage by taking her criminal lieutenant governor off the ticket? We live in a corrupt state run by corrupt Democrats.

t I totally agree with the mayors, not to mention I do not want my representative in Congress to be an insurrectionist. Even after the attack on her while in the Capitol still voted to not certify the legitamate election of the president . She also , in her sneaky remarks supports the Great Replacement Theory. 

It’s almost become normalized, and the Republicans have glossed over this so well.The bottom line is Stafanik did then, and likely still does support the lie that Biden’s victory is illegitimate and those thousands on 1/6 were just protesters, and btw, don’t bring up the 84 fake electors and the now well-documented plan to replace the will of the majority of Ameican voters.Every Republican who condones this needs to be held accountable and wear it like a facial tattoo. The mayors are to be applauded for their stance; not because it’s a Democratic one, but because it makes sense and the alternative to Mr. Tonko is a traitor. Too bad the Republicans can’t come up with real politicians.

William Marincic

I’m pretty sure the GOP will show you how many real politicians replace the hateful, power hungry, whacko democrats come November.

While sycophants of Donald Trump can only respond to his bad and likely illegal and traitorous behavior with empty bluster, reasonable law-abiding Americans are faced with this behavior from the same group:
“The fake electoral certificates were signed by Republican state lawmakers and party officials in Georgia, Arizona, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Nevada and New Mexico, states accounting for a combined 84 electoral votes. And like the violent insurrectionists who came to the Capitol on Jan. 6 with knives, bats and other weapons, the fake electors sought to overturn a democratic election through extralegal means. They did so in a coordinated effort, mostly out in the open, and through official channels.” -Politifact, January 28, 2022
And the reasonable, law-abiding Americans wonder how can that be acceptable?
Sycophants will only bray about ‘wait till November!’ We want to know: what if you lose?

William Marincic

Isn’t it funny that all of these do nothing mayors want to tilt the election in the favor of more do-nothing politicians. Not one of these cities is any better because of these mayors.

William Marincic

Sorry Richard, not snarky but I’m very informed and I personally know a couple of those Mayors and will be saying the same thing to them directly.

Leave a Reply