• SECTIONS
  • News
  • E-edition
  • Obituaries
  • Classified
  • Contact Us
  • The Daily Gazette
  • LOGIN
  • Subscribe

Subscriber login

Forgot Password?
Subscribe
LOGIN
  • News
    • Business
    • Schenectady County
    • Saratoga County
    • Fulton Montgomery Schoharie
    • News
  • Sports
    • High School Sports
    • College Sports
    • Parting Schotts
    • Union College
    • Siena College
    • UAlbany
    • Upstate Action
    • Sports
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Guest Column
    • Andrew Waite
  • Life and Arts
    • Art
    • Entertainment
    • Food
    • Special Sections
      • Outlook 2022
      • Local Bounty
      • Summer Travel 2022
      • Class of 2022
      • Fall Home 2022
      • Dig In! 2022
      • Celebrate 2022
      • Outlook 2023
  • Photo Galleries
  • Your City, Your Town
    • Your Niskayuna
    • Rotterdam
    • Scotia Glenville
    • Schenectady
    • Clifton Park and Halfmoon
    • Saratoga Springs
  • E-edition
  • Obituaries
  • Classified
    • CapRegion Cars
    • CapRegion Homes
    • CapRegion Jobs
  • Contact Us
Thursday, March 30, 2023 When credibility matters

Michelle vs. Michele: Ousted rank-and-file Dem, disability activist mounts bid against Ostrelich

By Tyler A. McNeil | March 17, 2023
Two photos of women
PHOTOGRAPHER: Photo Provided

Michele Dollar, left, has announced that she will seek the Democratic nomination for the Schenectady County Legislature seat in District 3 against incumbent Michelle Ostrelich, right.

Article Audio:

80

SHARES
Share on Facebook
Tweet
Follow us
Save
Share

SCHENECTADY COUNTY — There was a shakeup in Niskayuna Democratic politics last year when a group of progressives who were endorsed, in part, by Schenectady County Legislator Michelle Ostrelich ousted a number of longtime committee members.

Among those unseated from the Niskayuna Democratic Committee was disability advocate Michele Dollar, who’s now focused on knocking Ostrelich off the Democratic line in District 3, an area covering Niskayuna, Scotia and Glenville, in the race for the Schenectady County Legislature.

Primary elections are June 27.

“The decision was based on my own experiences with Ostrelich,” Dollar said in a text about choosing to run.

Such misgivings stem from the late 2010s when the now-lawmaker called on the Schenectady County Democratic Committee to embrace a more diverse nominee pool while not acknowledging Dollar, who uses a wheelchair due to complications with multiple sclerosis (all local Democratic committee members are also members of the larger countywide organization). Dollar felt “marginalized” by the experience.

Ostrelich said that she was addressing racial and ethnic diversity, and believed that the nomination pool outreach should expand.

Dollar’s frustrations continued to boil as then-committee incumbents last June learned about competitors days before the election — an anomaly in local party affairs.

“Her endless campaigning has stripped her of all self-awareness and empathy,” Dollar said in a statement. “I will be a county legislator for all residents of the District 3 — not just those who agree with me.”

Anonymous negative mailers were also sent out targeting the status quo on the Niskayuna Democratic Committee. Dollar filed a state Board of Elections complaint regarding the matter in November.

Ostrelich has disavowed the mailers and declined any association with it, but doesn’t regret the overall shakeup. She’s satisfied with the change.

“Our committee is now more diverse than it’s ever been in regard to racial diversity, ethnic diversity,” Ostrelich said. “And it’s filled with people who are working hard, want to be there and represent many aspects of Niskayuna, so the change has been incredibly positive.”

Dollar called Ostrelich’s involvement in the committee election a means of dismissing “the contributions of a woman of color, an LBGTQ+ young man, a Jewish senior citizen, me, and others all to further her own career.”

 Ostrelich was appointed and later elected to the county Legislature in 2019; she filled the seat of lifelong Republican James Buhrmaster. She unsuccessfully challenged seasoned GOP incumbent James Tedisco for a state Senate seat in 2018 and 2022.

Ostrelich, herself, was a registered Republican until 2017, a status she has linked to inheriting the party affiliation of her parents and attempting to bring the party “to the left” in primary elections. However, the GOP’s alignment toward Donald Trump was a deal-breaker.

Dollar, a lifelong Democrat and activist for disability rights, would be the only physically disabled lawmaker on the board if elected.

She has the backing of former Niskayuna Deputy Supervisor Lorene Zabin and town Democratic committeewoman Linda Rizzo, an outspoken Ostrelich critic.

The Schenectady County Democratic Committee on Jan. 26 endorsed District 3 legislators Ostrelich for a second term and Thomas Constantine for a fourth term.

Both candidates are running on a single ticket, despite broader ideological differences.

“She’s been fair to me,” Constantine said. “We do have a difference of political opinion as gets outside of Schenectady County.”

They both champion the Niskayuna Co-Op reconstruction project on Nott Street, a reconfiguration that Dollar believes stills lack accessibility and adequate parking. Ostrelich and Constantine disagree.

Constantine said that he wouldn’t mind running with Dollar should Ostrelich not win the Democratic line. He’s flattered that Dollar respects his work.

“Tom Constantine is a good man,” said Dollar in a text. “I look forward to running with him after I win this primary.”

Whoever wins the primary will go on to face town Republican Committee-endorsed candidates Stacie Agostino and Anthony Simone in the general election.

The GOP is also vying for two seats on the Niskayuna Town Board. Democrats have held a comfortable majority on the Town Board and all municipal affairs for years. In recent years, only two Republicans have held office — Town Supervisor Yasmine Syed, who did not seek re-election at the end of 2021, and Jason Moskowitz, who is currently the lone Republican on the council.

Voter enrollment data between 2008 and last year shows the number of registered Democrats growing from 5,877 to 7,804, Republicans dropping from 5,101 to 4,178 and independents growing from 4,323 to 5,109.

Ostrelich was the subject of a month-long anonymous ad blitz from a shadow group that went by the name The Kennedy Project last year. The group faced a volley of criticism after comparing the Jewish woman’s largely Jewish campaign staff to a British comedy sketch depiction of Nazis.

On the other hand, Ostrelich, among several others, currently faces a lawsuit alleging involvement in an anonymous online defamation campaign targeting former Niskayuna Councilwoman Denise Murphy McGraw’s daughter. The defendant filed a motion to dismiss, but the case is still ongoing, according to attorney Thomas Abinanti.

The junior McGraw has requested $1 million in damages per defendant.

Tyler A. McNeil can be reached at 518-395-3047 or [email protected] Follow him on Facebook at Tyler A. McNeil, Daily Gazette or Twitter @TylerAMcNeil

GAZETTE COVERAGE

Ensure access to everything we do, today and every day, check out our subscribe page at DailyGazette.com/Subscribe

More from The Daily Gazette:

  • The Mohonasen district sign reading Mohonasen WarriorsCapital Region school districts, including Mohonasen, Saratoga Springs, react to hoax shooter calls ...
  • An eagle in a carrier and an eagle flying away from a crowdBald eagle found near lifeless in Gilboa, now recovered, released back into wild in Schoharie County...
  • Mohonasen softball jerseyHigh schools: Mohonasen softball falls to Ichabod Crane
  • Man at podium with others behind him and stack of paper in front of him.State Sen. Tedisco calls for state budget transparency with proposed legislation
  • Two lacrosse players, one with the ballUnion rallies to beat arch-rival RPI in women's lacrosse

80

SHARES
Share on Facebook
Tweet
Follow us
Save
Share

Categories: Email Newsletter, News, Your Niskayuna

One Comment

Linda March 18th, 2023

Osterlich disavowed knowing anything about the June Primary brochures then why is Osterlich’s name and Supervisor Puccioni’s name on the brochures. Does Osterlich think that no one has a copy of these brochures?

As far as making the committee more diverse is also untrue. Unless you call diversity placing Osterlich and her friends in leadership positions on the committee.

Also if Osterlich cares so much for Schenectady County, why didn’t she join Jim Tedisco in his fight for the St. Clare’s pensioners? She put NO effort in this fight. Senator Tedisco, who she tried to defeat twice, has been recognized for his efforts by the pensioners and the Attorney General. Osterlich only fights for herself or for an issue that will garner her publicity. I can say one thing about her, she definitely does loves endless campaigns. Since 2017, this is her fourth campaign.

Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Digital Arcade

Advertisment

Auto Racing
Most read
  • Saratoga Springs schools, police investigating incident on West Circular St. Tuesday

  • Capital Region school districts, including Mohonasen, Saratoga Springs, react to hoax shooter calls Thursday

  • Bald eagle found near lifeless in Gilboa, now recovered, released back into wild in Schoharie County, DEC says

  • Scotia-Glenville High School production of ‘The Music Man’ to open

  • State Sen. Tedisco calls for state budget transparency with proposed legislation

Advertisement

Advertisment

Advertisement

The Daily Gazette The locally owned voice of the capital region
The Daily Gazette Co.
2345 Maxon Rd Ext.
Schenectady, NY 12308
Get Directions
(518) 374-4141
© 2023 The Daily Gazette   |   Privacy Policy   |   Terms of Service
Learn more about
The Daily Gazette
Advertise with
The Daily Gazette
Subscription Services
  • Subscribe
  • Pay my bill
  • Vacation Stop
  • Missed Delivery
  • Manage Digital Profile
  • Request Delivery Tube
  • Escalated Customer Service Concerns
  • Escalated Delivery Issues
Services
  • Advertise
  • Pay Advertising Invoice
  • E-Edition
  • E-Edition Tutorial Video
  • FAQ
  • LLC Legal Submission Form - Local
  • LLC Legal Submission Form - Agencies
  • Classified Ad Quote Request form
Quick Links
  • Add a Calendar Event
  • Area Legislators
  • Ask the Doctor
  • Best of Nominations
  • Careers
  • Contact Us
  • Contests & Promotions
  • Comics & Puzzles
  • Digital Arcade
  • Places of Worship
  • Submit a Letter
  • TV Listings
  • Gazette Logistics Employment Application
Other Publications & Events
  • 2023 Daily Gazette Wedding Show
  • The Gloversville Leader-Herald
  • The Amsterdam Recorder
Daily Gazette Newsletters
  • A.M. e-Edition Reminder Newsletter
  • Arts & Entertainment Newsletter
  • Sports Newsletter
  • Daily Obituary Newsletter
Partners
  • Image360 Graphics
© 2023 The Daily Gazette   |   Privacy Policy   |   Terms of Service
Fill out my online form.
Follow by Email
Facebook
Twitter
Reddit